307 Henry St., Suite 211, Alton, IL 62004    (618) 462-8484    Send a Message
307 Henry St., Suite 211, Alton, IL 62004
(618) 462-8484    Send a Message
Google Reviews - 5 Stars Leading Lawyers Super Lawyers

Posts Tagged ‘search and seizure’

Can the Government Use GPS Tracking Data without a Search Warrant?

Thursday, November 8th, 2012

Recently, USA v. Jones has landed in judicial limbo. First the conviction and the life sentence that resulted were thrown out in appeal by the Supreme Court on these grounds:
The Supreme Court tossed out GPS data that led to Jones’ conviction, along with Jones’ conviction and life term on Jan. 23 in one of the biggest cases in recent years dealing with technology and a citizens right to avoid unreasonable search and seizure.

“We hold that the government’s installation of a GPS device on a target’s vehicle, and its use of that device to monitor the vehicle’s movements, constitutes a ‘search,’” Justice Antonin Scalia wrote for the five-justice majority.

That decision, the Obama administration claimed, is “wholly inapplicable” when it comes to cell-site data.

USA v. Jones will soon be re-tried and prosecution will now try to use cell phone records to show where the accused was when making phone calls in 2005. The prosecution had 28 days worth of GPS tracking thrown out of their case because they did not receive a warrant for this information.

Cell-site data has been likened to bank records that can be obtained without a search warrant because they are public documents belonging to a “third party.” The verdict is still out on cell-site data. Will the information stand up in court?

John Stobbs, Criminal Defense Attorney

My Promise to You

"I'm not afraid to go to trial. I have been successful in fighting the government in trial and I have won acquittals in federal criminal jury trials. I fight hard for all of my clients. I fight hard to get good deals for my clients even if that means going to trial. The prosecutors know who the plea bargain lawyers are and who the attorneys are who fight hard for their clients! The prosectors are always going to give better deals to the attorneys that fight hard for their clients.

When you hire John Stobbs, you hire ME! I do all the work for your case - not a paralegal or an associate."

Request Your Free, Confidential Consultation


(618) 462-8484
Send a Message
Get Directions

Expert Criminal Defense Lawyer Serving


Edwardsville, IL
Alton, IL
Madison County
Southern Federal District of Illinois
Eastern Federal District of Missouri

Let's talk about your case.

Request a confidential appointment to explore how Stobbs Law Offices can assist in your aggressive legal defense.

Contact Us